Laneway Festival @ CircularQuay, Sydney (08/02/09)

www.fasterlouder.com.au
  • 59
  • 7
  • 1657

First of all, let it be known that I am old, and that I don’t care. Secondly, in deference to the current economic crisis, this review will cover each act in seven words or less. Unless they were especially good or terrible, in which case they will be allocated a little more. But not much! Words are expensive! Just like diamond-encrusted gold.

Secondly., I doubt I’m alone in having had the wind kicked completely out of me once I was finally able to get home on Sunday night, only to turn on the television and see that the better part of most of Victoria had burned to the ground. This is the kind of thing that makes sitting around on the internet arguing about what you thought of Tame Impala even more lame that it would normally be. So if you get nothing else out of reading this – please, donate some money you would otherwise dumbly waste on a Tame Impala CD to the Red Cross. YOU ARE THE OLYMPICS.

Oh, and lastly, the sound outdoors. Or rather, the lack thereof. I know there were drums on the Park stage, because I could see them, but I don’t think I heard a snare until Hold Steady. You are going to hear nothing but muck up the back of the Reiby Place stage, though the ancillary speakers did help. For future, just hire whoever it was that mixed All Tomorrow’s Parties and put them on a retainer for the next 15 years. Sorted. A gig without a good mix is like turducken without the bacon layer – it’s just not quite right. At all.

Whatever! Onwards!

Talons

Avidly Thrashing, Worthy Heirs To Further. Phwoar.

John Steel Singers

This Is Sure Some Irritating Scheduling. FAIL.

Papa vs Pretty

That’s Some Seriously Bullshit Awesome Guitar Playing. This band is in possession of maybe the best young guitar player in the land, even if said guitar is nearly as long as dude is tall (and apparently, used to belong to Simon Day.) Also, an incredible voice. They also have really weird song names like Emor ePerim and describe themselves as “nearly as intense as camping.” They touch on requisite influences without being overly derivative, a little like Muse crossed with the Doves garnished with tiny smatterings of Radiohead and In Utero Nirvana. Probably young enough to have been born in the – œ90s. Terrifying. (Very) Young Men Single-Handedly Save The Day.

Tame Impala

Easily The Most Overrated Band Since Wolfmother. If you were born in the 90s, you probably think this is, like, rad, dude. Otherwise you liked this band better when they were called Spiritualized.

Mountains In The Sky

Swell Integration Of So Many Lovely Machines. Ah, the Basement! Where sound has been balanced just as it should be since 18-something-or-other! I had never seen these guys before, and they were wonderful. “Hope you’re all ready to dance!” Well, yes, actually we were. Especially when the sound was driven along by such a calamitous drummer, drilling with all the ferocity and precision of an 808, only with lovely acoustic warmth. This was sweet, uplifting dreamscapes with solid, swinging underpinnings. Highly recommended.

ARGH! Daylight!

No Age

Fight With Radio DJs On Internet. Retract.

The Temper Trap

A U2-Loving Band That Doesn’t Suck! Temper Trap appear to have an almost heroic commitment to looking daggy (see: tracky dack bottoms and extremely high held bass guitars.) But they sound wonderful. I can’t help thinking that the huge cheer that greeted Sweet Disposition would probably have turned to murderous derision if someone had instead put on a copy of the Joshua Tree. Though that song sounds musically exactly like U2, it is better than anything Bono’s written in a decade. Also, undying kudos to anyone who covers Dancing in the Dark so winningly.

Stereolab

Clearly Not A Band Made For Touring. This was a really disappointing, lacklustre set, not helped by the fact that the wind whipped around the stage and blew away what might have remained of the mix. And so –
Tim Fite

Why Did I Not Come Here Earlier? Everyone gets to make one big mistake, right? Damn you, Stereolab! How can someone who looks so thoroughly bizarre (Humpty Tin Tin) make such stunningly beautiful, stunningly strange and eclectic music? Profanity-laced hip hop country folk.? No problem.

The Drones

Here’s The Invasion of the Girl Talk People. Is there a harder working, more universally beloved band in the country than the Drones? I doubt it. Even if they were shuffled onto a different stage, and halfway through their set the great sea of Girl Talk people began their descent, elbowing heads as they plundered, and so we left, confident that we will see the Drones many more times. And likely somewhere where we can both see and hear them.

The Hold Steady

Not Just Anyone Rocks Double Necked Guitars. Classic rock is back, but it’s somehow cool when it’s from Brooklyn via Minneapolis. I’m not complaining, I’ll take big riffs, meat and potatoes drum fills and audience singalongs anyway I can get them. A thankfully upbeat way to call it a very long day.

  • asb123
  • Esmerelda
  • JackT
  • brownie-ll
  • Ginger Ninja
  • sarahanne
  • NickHallworth

Comments

www.fasterlouder.com.au arrow left
20910
clashpalace

clashpalace said on the 17th Feb, 2009



Call me arrogant, it is not ignorance of the issue. I could write an essay on it but it's not worth my time.

I think his remixes are pretty darn good. They get you dancing. My comment was just touching the surface on what I think about 'mashupers'. I don't classify them as artists. Nor are they on par with producers or composers.

The fact of the matter is if you locked girl talk in a room with every instrument possible and all the electronic equipment and pc's used for cutting/editing then you wouldn't get anything good out of it, without giving him other peoples music (which they worked hard to produce/write)

It's not even a diss against DJ's... the good ones take average songs, add their own spins and chuck them in a different direction that makes you say wow. Two albums as a perfect example of this are the remixes featured on bloc party's silent alarm remixed, dfa1979's romance bloody romance and hell even local act gotye's like drawing blood remixed.

Grabbing a shopping list of classic/famous songs across various genres and putting them together to dance beats is fine for dance party's at your place. But putting the same CD on at a supposedly live gig and then dancing around with ur hands in the air in a way that would make kanye west seem modest. It just doesnt cut it for me. Nor does selling yourself as an International artist via such means. I'm not going to pay money to see a CD player and a guy on pils 'live' ?

But it's the in thing now, who am I to diss girl talk? He definitely had the most attendance at laneway... I got elbowed in the head several times trying to squeeze from the front of the drones towards the back/exit for girltalk. I'm sure everyone enjoyed themselves. I didnt.

brownie-ll

brownie-ll said on the 19th Feb, 2009



So now your informed opinion on Girl Talk comes from seeing Cut Copy? Maybe you can tell me your informed opinion of The Hold Steady based off seeing to The Mountain Goats too?



If Girl Talk pressed random buttons of other people's music when performing, I'd agree. But as previously explained, his sequencing employs reading his audience and making changes on the fly. That takes both skill and dedication to master, and takes more then just pressing a button every five minutes.

I'd imagine you wouldn't be a fan of someone like Grandmaster Flash, or The Avalanches, or Steinski who are known for playing samples from other artists or even *gasp* entire songs from other artists, right? Spinning records whilst pressing some buttons every now and again, they're not even playing guitars! Some originality they have!



I won't argue that the music Girl Talk makes is unique or special, because it isn't. People will get sick of the hyphy over 80s pop and Gregg Gillis will either try something new, go back to making glitch, or fade away. But you never hear of Gillis talking about his "art" or what impact he's making on music. He's a dude who takes disposable music (that quite often isn't good on it's own) and makes it even more disposable in order to have some fun. If there's anything amusing about what he does, it's that he's been able to turn it into a full time career.

Just because you stick your hands in front of your eyes while yelling "NAH NAH NAH I'M NOT READING" doesn't make your uneducated opinion right. So I'm going to encourage you to keep on posting those opinions here so you can prove how ill-informed on music you are. I'd suggest starting with a thread asking [URL="http://www.fasterlouder.com.au/forum/showthread.php?t=20835"]why anyone would play Guitar Hero over a real guitar, but it looks like that one has already been claimed.

clashpalace

clashpalace said on the 19th Feb, 2009

Normally I don't get dragged into these types of situations. But you've crossed the line and called me ill informed about music. Im a bit of a music nerd actually. So now... I'm happy to play

I took one look at your last.fm and laughed my fucking ass off. Some half good rap tastes aside, You have 50cent in your top10. What are you doing on fasterlouder exactly? Shouldn't you be hanging out in da club? bottle full of bub?

Stop cutting up my quotes and then going off on random tangents:

I stated I wasn't a fan of button pushers only and hence made the microwave clock remark.
--You stated it's the norm for electronic artists

I stated Cut Copy play almost all of their stuff live and focused on the fact that its THEIR stuff Not so much the button pushing.
--You accused me of being hypocritical of button pushers?

You then posted the same microwave clock quote this time saying its ill-informed of electronic music
--I stated I've seen a few electronica style acts in my day such as Cut Copy. Hence my comparison with them as true artists; playing their own music and doing it mostly live in comparison to girltalk who plays other peoples music to lesser(almost no?) extent live.

And now your saying my informed opinion of girltalk comes from cutcopy
Huh?

I saw girltalk at laneway. Didnt like it. Let's not get personal.

50cent in da house y0.
P.S I luv y0 brimmed hat display pic. Do Y0u hAv a de4l3r wh0 can get me sUm che4p? It m4k3z da laddies cr34m